'The Butler' - Was Oscar Talk a Tad Premature? Reviews Are In!

Subscribe to Forest Whitaker alerts

While The Butler seemed like an early contender for Oscar contention, the early reviews suggest it may have fallen short in some areas. Praised were the performances, especially Forest Whitaker's, but criticized is the depth of this ambitious movie.

Forest Whitaker and Cuba Gooding Jr in The ButlerForest Whitaker and Cuba Gooding Jr in The Butler

“Whitaker digs in deep and gives a marvelous under-the-skin performance; he seems to catch the very essence of a man who has spent his whole life trying not to be seen,” say Variety. “A great film about the American civil rights movement is way overdue. The Butler, overwhelmed by flash and good intentions, doesn't even come close,” The Guardian write in their review.

Entertainment Weekly call The Butler “An ambitious, sweeping period drama that manages to be incredibly affecting and feel as if the words ''For Your Consideration'' are stamped across every frame.” “Squeezing a miniseries' worth of drama into a feature-length film, this impassioned story simply doesn't have the time to really delve into the epochal periods it chronicles,” say Screen International.

Check out The Butler Trailer

This to-and-froing of reviews has culminated in a 75% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, meaning the next few days are vital. If the upcoming slew of critical responses agree with the naysayers, we could be seeing something near the 60% mark, but if Whitaker’s performances continues to charm, we’ll be approaching the mid-80’s.

Either way, it would appear as though The Butler is a solid effort, telling the story of a White House butler who served eight American presidents over three decades, while chronicling the civil rights movement in America. Perhaps, though, it’s too much to try and tell both stories, entwined as they are.

Terrence Howard and Oprah Winfrey in The ButlerTerrence Howard and Oprah Winfrey in The Butler


Tags: Forest Whitaker - Oprah Winfrey - Cuba Gooding Junior

Subscribe to Forest Whitaker alerts

More Forest Whitaker

Jake Gyllenhaal Gets Ripped For Southpaw: Is There Anything He Can't Do?

Jake Gyllenhaal is a shape shifter. There is no other explanation. We barely recognised him whilst he was filming 'Nightcrawler', with his sunken cheeks and...

Taken 3 Trailer

Things are finally quieting down for Bryan Mills (Liam Neeson). After the ex-special forces operative tracked down and returned his daughter (Maggie Grace), then his...

Fruitvale Station Movie Review

With his debut feature, writer-director Ryan Coogler recreates a real-life event with remarkable artistry. Even though the factual story is overwhelmed with emotion and political...

Is Forest Whitaker Set To Direct 'The Shack' Adaptation?

Oscar winner Forest Whitaker could be the man to direct the big screen version of The Shack, Deadline is reporting. Written by William Paul Young,...


Out of the Furnace Movie Review

Coarse and not exactly subtle, this dark drama might disappoint viewers expecting a more traditional revenge thriller, but there's something more interesting going on here....

A Week In Movies: Stars court awards attention at premieres, while Bieber hits the red carpet and several new trailers arrive

Two big premieres this week were more about raising awards-worthy awareness than launching a movie. Meryl Streep, Julia Roberts, Ewan McGregor, Chris Cooper, Abigail Breslin...

Repentance Trailer

Thomas Carter is a life coach who receives widespread literary fame after releasing his book 'Don't Look Back' following a nearly fatal car accident. At...

Forget the Screen Actors Guild Nominees, WHO GOT SNUBBED?!

This morning we were treated to the Screen Actors Guild (SAG) nominations. It's one of the biggest award ceremonies on the movie calendar and, well,...



Forest Whitaker Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Forest Whitaker

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All