Channel 5's "Big Benefits Row" Recap: Where Shouting Trumps Facts

Organize a panel on one of the most controversial issues out there and then invite one of the most polarizing TV personalities to discuss – Channel 5’s Big Benefits Row certainly had the right idea when it comes to boosting ratings. It’s questionable whether Katie Hopkins, Deirdre Kelly or ‘White Dee’ from controversial Channel 4 documentary Benefits Street and ex-Tory MP Edwina Currie ever had a chance at some kind of productive discussion about whether the benefits system should be changed, but that was not what happened during the show.

Katie Hopkins, ITV Studios
Katie Hopkins was her usual loud and vibrant self.

Dee made a surprisingly composed and coherent first live TV appearance. Making her case, she said: "I haven't been on benefits my whole life. It’s just at the moment. I suffer from depression and I'm being assessed for bipolar disorder."

As ever ready with a quick and loud rebuttal, Hopkins took aim at Kelly, asking: “Do you not feel like the patron saint of druggies and drop-outs?”

As the debate got more and more heated, the studio audience eagerly joined in, particularly those other Benefits Street present in the studio. Shouts of “My CV is in every single shop!" and "I do not sit on my bum all day!” weren’t too helpful in moving the debate forward, but they provided appropriate ambiance for the heated argument.

Matthew Wright
Matthew Wright was on hosting duty, but by the end, he could barely get a word in edgewise.

The Independent columnist Owen Jones, Spectator editor Fraser Nelson and poverty campaigner Jack Monroe joined in with the general sentiment that programmes like Benefits Street help demonize people, who at one time or another live on benefits. In classic style, however, Hopkins rebuffed and drowned out their arguments with a couple of long-winded tangents.

A live shout-off followed, with host Matthew Wright poking and prodded with such questions as "What about tax avoidance?" In the end, they helped elevate the noise levels, but did not draw out a clear end or conclusion from the debate. It was certainly watchable, and had mild entertainment value. However, as an actual discussion on benefits or even a barometer of public opinion, The Big Benefits Row wasn’t all that helpful.


Contactmusic

Tags: Katie Hopkins


Editors Recommendations

Is The Cannes Palme d'Or Heading David Cronenberg’s Way for 'Map to the Stars'?

The Cannes Film festival is sneaking up fast. The Oscars felt like they were 8 minutes ago...

Is The Cannes Palme d'Or Heading David Cronenberg’s Way for 'Map to the Stars'?

CounterPoint Festival 2014 To Feature Hometown Return of Outkast

Next weekend's CounterPoint Festival will be the event's first year at a new 5000-acre site, featuring...

CounterPoint Festival 2014 To Feature Hometown Return of Outkast

'The Amazing Spider-Man 2' - Not Perfect, But Really, Really Fun

Superhero movies have been striving towards the almost unobtainable goal set...

'The Amazing Spider-Man 2' - Not Perfect, But Really, Really Fun

Ricky Gervais is "Hooked" on David Brent Again - Former Paper Merchant To Return

A return for David Brent has been mooted ever since the character was wheeled...

Ricky Gervais is

This Labor Day, Jay Z Is Bringing "Made In America" To Downtown Los Angeles

Jay Z and the Mayor of Los Angeles Eric Garcetti have announced that the rapper’s...

This Labor Day, Jay Z Is Bringing

Anna Wintour wants 'more exclusive' Met Ball 2014

The editor-in-chief of US VOGUE magazine is reportedly determined for the annual...

Anna Wintour - Anna Wintour wants 'more exclusive' Met Ball 2014

'Mrs Doubtfire' Sequel Will Be Made 21 Years After The Original

The comedy classic 'Mrs. Doubtfire' is reportedly set to return to the big-screen...

'Mrs Doubtfire' Sequel Will Be Made 21 Years After The Original

'Of Mice And Men' Brings Out Broadway Talents Of James Franco, Chris O'Dowd

Of Mice And Men premiered on Broadway last night, giving critics a chance to cast...

'Of Mice And Men' Brings Out Broadway Talents Of James Franco, Chris O'Dowd

Sofia Vergara On Her Menage a Trois in Woody Allen's 'Fading Gigolo'

Sofia Vergara has been speaking about her nerves at shooting a ménage a trois with...

Sofia Vergara On Her Menage a Trois in Woody Allen's 'Fading Gigolo'


More recommendations

Comments

Katie Hopkins Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Katie Hopkins

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All