Should Sam Bailey Be Allowed To Remain on The X-Factor?

Sam Bailey, the current joint-favourite to win this year's X-Factor competition, has hit back at critics who claim she shouldn't be allowed to compete on the show owing to her extensive musical experience.

The prison officer stunned judges Gary Barlow, Nicole Scherzinger, Sharon Osbourne and Louis Walsh during her show-stopping auditions on Saturday and Sunday, though a report in The Sun newspaper claimed Sam had "misled the public" by appearing to be a novice with an exceptional gift for singing.

In fact, the newspaper claims Bailey has been singing for years in social clubs, on cruises and for charity shows - something they doesn't dispute - and shouldn't be allowed to compete against the likes of Tamera Foster, the young Beyonce-a-like who is likely to be her nearest rival.

"I have been totally honest that I have sang for 20 years but never made it. What's the problem with that?" Bailey told the Leicester Mercury this week, "I've been performing on and off for years but I've never been given that big break and the chance to stand out as a solo artist.In the work I've done I've always been bottom billing - even the bingo comes above me - and it's never been enough to pay the bills or earn a decent living, that's why for the past three years I've been working as a prison officer."

Bailey received a standing ovation at London's Wembley Stadium on Sunday evening (September 1, 2013) for her rendition of The Jacksons's 'Who's Lovin You.'

Yesterday, an X-Factor spokesman confirmed that Bailey had auditioned in 2007 though never made it in front of the judges.

"Sam has never been on any TV talent show, as she was not successful in the producers' auditions in 2007 and did not see the judges," the spokesman said. "Sam works full time as a prison officer and while she has done some singing work in the past such as charity gigs and performing in social clubs, she has never been able to make a living out of it or done anything on the scale of her X Factor audition in front of 5,000 people."

Watch Sam Bailey's X-Factor Audition:

The defensive statement appears to suggest Bailey will be making it through to the latter rounds of the competition, though it reignites the debate over what The X-Factor is really meant for in the first place. Unearthing fresh new talent?

Nicole ScherzingerSam Bailey's Performance At Wembley Stunned Judge Nicole Scherzinger


Tags: The X Factor - Sam Bailey


More The X Factor

Cheryl Cole Loves Her Girls - On The "X Factor" That Is

Wait, is it X Factor time again? When did this happen? The mentors – this year’s lineup is Cheryl Cole, Mel B, Simon Cowell and...

X Factor Judges Star In £1million 'Game Of Thrones Promo'

The latest series of the X Factor looks set to be the most epic one yet - if the first promo is anything to go...

Rebecca Ferguson's Family Members Shot in Drive-By Shooting

Two members of Rebecca Ferguson's family have been shot in a drive-by shooting in Everton. The singer is said to be "shocked and terrified" by...

'I Can't Sing!' Villain Trevor Modo Based on James Arthur?

A hunchback villain character named Trevor Modo in Harry Hill's new X-Factor musical I Can't Sing! is apparently based on former champion James Arthur. In...


'X-Factor' Musical 'I Can't Sing' Becomes West End's Guilty Pleasure

You would have been forgiven for completely forgetting about Harry Hill's X-Factor musical 'I Can't Sing', with that bloke from Eastenders playing Simon Cowell, but...

Cheryl Cole Confirms X-Factor Return, But Is It Too Late?

Cheryl Cole - one of the biggest celebrity names in the UK despite taking several years out of the limelight - has confirmed she is...

X-Factor Viewer? Yeah, Chris O'Dowd Thinks You're a Racist.

The Bridesmaids actor Chris O'Dowd says he is a "big X Factor fan" though feels for black contestants because the "the viewing public is so...

Louis Walsh Set To Launch All-New Boyband In 2014

Louis Walsh will launch his latest pop creation in 2014, with the Irish music mogul announcing his plans to oversee the launch of a new...



RandelC's picture


There is no denying Sam's right to be on X Factor. She's earned it the hard way.

4 months 5 days ago
View Comments

Skint's picture


Some people can sing - I say, go for it...

11 months 3 weeks ago
View Comments

Skint's picture


I say all the best to Sam - Hopes she makes it...

11 months 3 weeks ago
View Comments

The X Factor Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on The X Factor

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All