Why, Oh Why, Couldn't Aronofsky Write and Direct 'RoboCop'?

Subscribe to Joel Kinnaman alerts

José Padilha's remake of RoboCop has severely divided critics ahead of its release on Friday (February 7, 2014) and sits around the 50% fresh mark on reviews aggregating website Rotten Tomatoes. The remake of the cult 1987 action movie treads similar ground: the year is 2028, conglomerate OnmiCorp take advantage of a critically injured police officer to develop a part-man, part robot officer to stem the tide of crime and corruption in Detroit.

Joel Kinnaman RoboCopJoel Kinnaman as RoboCop

It's a great idea for a movie. The original movie was great, and there were high hopes that the inevitable remake could add something to the genre when Darren Aronofsky and David Self were assigned to write and direct in 2005. The movie was delayed numerous times and the acclaimed filmmaker moved onto other projects, handing Padilha (Elite Squad) the reins.

In the completed movie, The Killing's Joel Kinnaman plays RoboCop, with an all-star supporting cast including Gary Oldman, Michael Keaton, Samuel L. Jackson and Abbie Cornish. 

"This remake of the 1987 dystopian classic has a better cast, more meticulous script and, naturally, flashier effects, but it lacks the original's wit and subversive slipperiness," said the Hollywood Reporter.

Robocop remakeRoboCop Has Divided Critics

"A futuristic action thriller with more heart and character interest than the 1987 original but not the excitement, surprise or powerful satiric edge," said the Daily Express.

"It's a less playful enterprise than the original, but meets the era's darker demands for action reboots with machine-tooled efficiency and a hint of soul," wrote Variety.

"Throughout, one character refers to the new RoboCop as 'Tin Man' and to the film's credit, it desperately wants to have a heart. Oh, if it only had a brain," said Empire magazine.

"If there had to be a RoboCop remake, it might as well have been this one," said the Playlist.

Check back on Friday when we'll have a full RoboCop review.

Watch the RoboCop trailer:


Tags: Joel Kinnaman

Subscribe to Joel Kinnaman alerts

More Joel Kinnaman

The Final Season Of 'The Killing' - What's The Verdict?

Maybe it shouldn't have ended so soon, but at least it got the ending it deserved. After being canceled twice by its network AMC, cult-detective...

Everything Is Doom And Gloom In First Trailer For "The Killing" Final Season

Four seasons in, Netflix’s The Killing is getting the axe in 2015. Judging from the first trailer for the final season though, the show is...

What To Expect From The Final Season Of 'The Killing'

‘The Killing’ just can’t be killed. AMC’s cult crime drama thriller premiered on the network in 2011, but was quickly canceled following its second season....

Easy Money II Trailer

JW has served three years of his prison sentence so far after being arrested for smuggling cocaine. Once a gifted business student at the Stockholm...


Valentine's Day Cinema? See 'Robocop' And Avoid The PDA Space Invasion [Trailer]

Valentines Day 2014: will you be heading to catch one of the cleverly-marketed lovers' day releases this year? Well there's plenty of them to choose...

'Robocop' Remake Fails To Distract Critics From 1987 Comparisons

Robocop has failed to impress critics following its release in the US yesterday (12th January). Reviews have primarily focussed on comparisons between the original 1987...

The New "RoboCop" Is Shiny, But Heartless, Say Critics

So far, despite a rather touching performance by Gary Oldman, a suitably repulsive turn as the villain by Michael Keaton and, of course, the ever...

'Mr Peabody' Takes Down 'Robocop', Because Robocop is Rubbish

While Robocop was staring over a dystopian land, contemplating whether to fight crime or corruption, or both, Sherman knelt down behind him and Mr. Peabody...



Joel Kinnaman Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Joel Kinnaman

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All