What Would 'Harry Potter' Have Been Like With This Alternative Cast?

There’s a generation out there who have been practically weened on Harry Potter. The books and the films have become a religion for devout fans of the series, but would it have been the same if different actors had been cast in the leading roles? You may be surprised to hear that before the perfect cast was set in stone, there were some strange alternate actors vying for the parts!

ian mckellen harry potterIan McKellen turned down the role of Dumbledore

Sir. Ian McKellen was once thought in the running to play Hogwarts’ headmaster, Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore. He was, in fact, offered the role after original Dumbledore actor, Richard Harris, passed away just after filming the first Harry Potter film. However, Sir. Ian turned down the role, citing the reason that Richard Harris had once publicly declared what a dreadful actor he thought McKellen was! Eventually, Michael Gambon took on the role and the rest is Harry Potter history.

Floppy haired Lothario, Hugh Grant, was considered for the role of fame hungry Gilderoy Lockhart. Hugh certainly would have brought Gilderoy’s good looks to life, but wasn’t able to take on the role due to scheduling conflicts. Kenneth Branagh won the role and while he may not be as conventionally handsome as Hugh, he certainly gives Gilderoy that air of nonsensical arrogance that J.K. bestows upon him in the books.

Tilda Swinton was believed to be almost cast as wacky divination professor, Sybill Trelawny, losing out on the role to British treasure, Emma Thompson. Emma was certainly a solid choice for the producers and she definitely pins down Professor Trelawny’s endearing naivety - would Tilda Swinton have been better in the role? What do you think?

We can’t imagine anyone being able to add such a delightful spark of madness and villainy to Bellatrix LeStrange as Helena Bonham-Carter. Helena is famed for playing off-the-wall characters, so seems like the ideal candidate, but Helen McCrory, who went on to play Narcissa Malfoy, was also initially said to be in the running for the role! Not only was Helen in the running for Bellatrix, but Naomi Watts was also potentially going to play Narcissa! Mind. Blown.

helena bonham carter harry potterFans love wacky Helena Bonham-Carter as Bellatrix LeStrange

Everybody’s favourite ambiguously allied potions master, Severus Snape, was a character practically written for Alan Rickman. Rickman’s drawling voice and stone-set face made him a firm favourite with fans, but the role of Snape was toss up between him and fellow British actor Tim Roth. Can you think of any actor more perfect for the role than Alan Rickman?

Finally, no one could imagine anyone other than Daniel Radcliffe as Harry Potter, Dan having played the role since he was a little boy. However, American actor, Liam Aiken was initially up for the part. Ultimately, producers wanted a Brit to play the part and so chose Dan-Rad. Don’t feel too sorry for Liam though, he went onto star in Road to Perdition with Tom Hanks and A Series of Unfortunate Events with Jim Carrey.

Liam AikenImaginging Liam Aiken as Harry Potter? No, We Can't.


Tags: Ian McKellen - Daniel Radcliffe - Tilda Swinton - Emma Thompson - Hugh Grant - Liam Aiken


More Ian Mckellen

Sir Ian McKellen Inspires Bristol Students With Famous Gandalf Line

Sir Ian McKellen has given students at Chew Valley School in Bristol a day they’ll never forget, after he delivered one of his most famous...

Film Franchises That Go On Forever

The Hobbit trilogy has been criticised by some viewers for having too little content spread too thinly over the course of too many films. Originally,...

Middle Earth is Ravaged By War in 'The Hobbit: The Battle of The Five Armies' [Trailer + Pictures]

As promised by the release of Smaug from Eribor, war has descended upon Middle Earth and threatens to strip landscape of peace, serenity and beauty....

The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies Trailer

Bilbo Baggins, Gandalf and the mini-army of dwarves led by Thorin are facing an evermore deadly path in their pursuit of the Lonely Mountain and...


'The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies' Gets a Facebook Photo Tease

‘The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies’ won’t be out for another 6 months, which means it’s just the right time to start dripping...

Why Daniel Day-Lewis Deserves His Knighthood

Few actors impart an intensity and dedication to the process of characterization as relentlessly as Daniel Day-Lewis. The 57 year-old occupies a position in the...

X-men: Days of Future Past Movie Review

Continuing to be the most original and resonant of the Marvel superhero franchises, the X-men return in the capable hands of director Bryan Singer, who...

With 95%, 'X-Men: Days of Future Past' Is The Best X-Men Movie. Period.

The early reviews of X-Men: Days of Future Past were potentially damaging. There was talk of the narrative being far too complex for the average...



Lee Adams's picture

Lee Adams

An interesting way of looking at the harry Potter brand, when I think Harry Potter I see the cast we all know

8 months 4 days ago
View Comments

Ian McKellen Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Ian McKellen

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All