Lee Daniels' The Butler Is "Deeply Affecting And Oscar Bait"

Lee Daniels' The Butler is released today in US cinemas. Early reviews of the historical drama have been mixed although most suggest the film is definitely worth a watch.

Forest Whitaker and Oprah WinfreyForest Whitaker and Oprah Winfrey at the L.A. premiere of The Butler.

The film has been praised by critics for being "both deeply affecting and blatant Oscar bait", according to Claudia Puig of USA Today. Whilst Joe Morgenstern of the Wall Street Journal wrote in his review "fiction merges with fact, and finally soars."

The Butler tells the story of Cecil Gaines, a butler who served eight presidents at the White House. His life forms a perfect narrative for the Civil Rights movement including the rise of Martin Luther King to prominence and the Black Power movement. 

Most critics have responded favourably to the film. Those who have some criticism have largely emphasised the positives of the historical epic, as Peter Travers of Rolling Stone commented "there's no denying the stumbles that mar this alternately riveting and risible historical epic." However, he continues by stating "Lee Daniels' The Butler holds you, provokes you and ultimately moves you." 

Jane Fonda
Jane Fonda at the New York premiere of The Butler.

Indeed in a similar fashion, Ben Sachs of the Chicago Reader epitomised this train of thought by saying "the movie's a mess, but a unique and provocative one."

Mike LaSalle of the San Francisco Chronicle appears to have taken a lengthy liquid lunch before writing his reviews, as he not only criticises the script as "mostly silly", but claims that Lee Daniel's casting decisions are "the craziest and most laughable casting imaginable."

The film stars Forest Whitaker, as Gaines, who is the brilliant actor who brought Ugandan dictator Idi Amin to life in The Last King of Scotland.  Oprah Winfrey, won a Golden Globe for her performance as Sofia in The Color Purple, plays his wife Gloria. 

Watch the movie trailer for Lee Daniels' The Butler:

Watch more clips from Lee Daniels' The Butler on Contactmusic.

The two powerhouses are supported by the likes of John Cusack, James Marsden and Robin Williams who play some of the eight presidents Gaines serves. Not only are the men of the White House portrayed in the film but their families too. For instance Marsden takes on the role of President Kennedy with Minka Kelly as Jackie. Later, Jane Fonda plays Nancy Reagan with Alan Rickman as her husband Ronald. 

With such a stellar cast including award winner actors, LaSalle appears slightly unjustified in his criticism of this aspect of the film. 

Lee Daniels' The Butler is due to be released in US cinemas today (16th August). 

Minka Kelly
Minka Kelly at the New York premiere.


Contactmusic

Tags: Forest Whitaker - Oprah Winfrey - Alan Rickman - Minka Kelly - Jane Fonda - John Cusack - Robin Williams - James Marsden

Advertisement

More Forest Whitaker

Fruitvale Station Movie Review

With his debut feature, writer-director Ryan Coogler recreates a real-life event with remarkable artistry. Even though the factual story is overwhelmed with emotion and political...

Is Forest Whitaker Set To Direct 'The Shack' Adaptation?

Oscar winner Forest Whitaker could be the man to direct the big screen version of The Shack, Deadline is reporting. Written by William Paul Young,...

Out of the Furnace Movie Review

Coarse and not exactly subtle, this dark drama might disappoint viewers expecting a more traditional revenge thriller, but there's something more interesting going on here....

A Week In Movies: Stars court awards attention at premieres, while Bieber hits the red carpet and several new trailers arrive

Two big premieres this week were more about raising awards-worthy awareness than launching a movie. Meryl Streep, Julia Roberts, Ewan McGregor, Chris Cooper, Abigail Breslin...

Advertisement

Repentance Trailer

Thomas Carter is a life coach who receives widespread literary fame after releasing his book 'Don't Look Back' following a nearly fatal car accident. At...

Forget the Screen Actors Guild Nominees, WHO GOT SNUBBED?!

This morning we were treated to the Screen Actors Guild (SAG) nominations. It's one of the biggest award ceremonies on the movie calendar and, well,...

A Week In Movies: Catching Fire lands in cinemas, Black Nativity premieres, a first peek into Noah's ark

This week is pretty much all about The Hunger Games as Catching Fire arrives in cinemas around the world. After last week's world premiere in...

Forest Whitaker Takes Family To 'Black Nativity' NY Premiere - Part 3

'Black Nativity' Forest Whitaker arrived with his wife Keisha Nash Whitaker and daughter Sonnet Whitaker at the movie's New York premiere held at the Apollo...

Advertisement

Comments

Forest Whitaker Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Forest Whitaker

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All