Jon Stewart's 'Rosewater' Is Good, But Were We Expecting More?

Subscribe to Jon Stewart alerts

Jon Stewart's directorial debut Rosewater premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on Friday (August 27, 2014) and the critics and bloggers were quick off the mark with their reactions. 

RosewaterBernal [L] and Stewart [R] backstage on the set of 'Rosewater'

Based on a real-life incident - which sort of intertwined with Stewart's satirical programme The Daily Show - Rosewater tells the story of Iranian journalist Maziar Bahari (Gael Garcia Bernal) who covered the 2009 elections in his home country for Newsweek before getting detained by the Iranian government following an appearance on Stewart's show. 

More: First look at Jon Stewart's 'Rosewater'

More: For Jon Stewart, the Toronto Film Festival is just another day's work

Stewart famously took time off from his nightly TV show to head to Jordan and film the adaptation of Bahari's account of his horrifying experience, Then They Came For Me. So was it worth it?

"An emotionally accessible but very modest tale of one man's temporary misfortune at the hands of the Iranian government," said Todd McCarthy.

Gael Garcia BernalGael Garcia Bernal plays journalist Maziar Bahari in 'Rosewater'

"Stewart maintains a serenely unsettling tension throughout. Perhaps more impressively, he's made a movie of the moment that doesn't feel like a sententious "issue" drama, and is all the more affecting for it," said Scott Foundas of Variety, "Through Bahari's eyes, and with utmost respect for the Iranian people, "Rosewater" gazes out at a nation flirting perilously with a new era of social liberties, and finds glimmers of hope in the darkness."

".the film understandably sets aside Stewart's trademark barbed humor in a story that needs to be told without mockery or laughs, and it's also more earnest than Stewart's TV fans might expect," said Steve Pond at The Wrap.

More: Is 'Rosewater' the next Argo?


Tags: Jon Stewart - Gael Garcia Bernal

Subscribe to Jon Stewart alerts

More Jon Stewart

Colbert Conquers Death In Comedy Central Finale

It’s over. It’s done. Colbert is dead. Long live Colbert. The Colbert Report aired its final episode last night – Thursday, December 18. The show...

Jon Stewart Apologises To Southern California D.A. Over 'Daily Show' Segment

Jon Stewart has apologised to a San Bernardino D.A. on Friday after including a local incident where a man died in custody after he had...

Dave Grohl Hints At Second Series Of 'Sonic Highways'

Foo Fighters’ frontman Dave Grohl has hinted that there might be a second season of ‘Sonic Highways’. Ahead of the release of their recent album...

Jon Stewart Says What Everyone Is Thinking (And Tweeting) On The Eric Garner Case

So we can all agree that things are pretty bad after the Mike Brown and Eric Garner cases, right? That was pretty much the point...


Could Jon Stewart's 'Rosewater' Have a Shot at the Oscars?

Rosewater, Jon Stewart's directorial debut based on the best-selling memoir Then They Came For Me: A Family's Story of Love, Captivity and Survival by Maziar...

A Week In Movies: Stars Descend On London, While New Trailers Premiere For The Edward Snowden Doc And Films With Shailene Woodley, Jennifer Lopez And Chris Hemsworth

Everyone who's anyone was in London this week for the 58th BFI London Film Festival, which held gala premieres for the likes of Wild (with...

Jon Stewart Couldn't Be Bought For Meet The Press

Jon Stewart has been fronting The Daily Show since 1999 and has been doing an exceptionally good job for 15 years. Ratings are regularly awesome,...

Rosewater Trailer

Maziar Bahari is an Iranian-Canadian journalist who embarked on a week long trip to Iran in 2009 in a bid to cover the story of...



Jon Stewart Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Jon Stewart

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All