Could Terry Gilliam Have Directed Harry Potter?

Fourteen years ago the question of which director would be responsible for bringing the 'Harry Potter' franchise to the big screen was one of the most debated film topics. Chris Columbus got the job, but Terry Gilliam wanted it and the director expressed his annoyance at not be given the role at the time. Now with the benefit of hindsight who really would have been better at taking on the unenviable task of directing 'Harry Potter'.

Could Terry Gilliam have done a better job than Chris Columbus?Could Terry Gilliam have done a better job than Chris Columbus?

Who ever was given the task of bringing ‘Harry Potter’ to life onscreen for the first time was going to be carrying the hopes and expectations of millions children all over the world. This meant that the task of picking the first director would not be easy. Among the names talked about early on, were Steven Spielberg, (who wished to animate the films), Tim Robbins and M. Night Shyamalan. However Rowling’s personal pick was Terry Gilliam, whom the author was a fan of. Gilliam said in 2006 that he was the ‘perfect guy’ to direct ‘Harry Potter’, but the gig went to Chris Columbus.

Gilliam definitely had an impressive back catalogue, especially in the fantasy genre. Looking at ‘Time Bandits’ and his later works ‘Brothers Grimm’ and ‘The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus’, it’s clear Gilliam would have had the imagination to bring the ‘Harry Potter’ books to life on screen. Columbus’s previous work was less impressive. Yes ‘Home Alone’, ‘Home Alone 2’ and ‘Mrs Doubtfire.’ were box office hits aimed at a younger audience, but they were a far cry from a story with as much depth and imagination as 'Harry Potter'. What was in Columbus’s favour though was that he had written two eighties cult classics, ‘Gremlins’ and ‘The Goonies’.

What went against Gilliam was more his reputation especially when it came to budgetary matters.
Gilliam had a reputation of making movies with extremely inflated budgets, for example ‘The Adventures of Baron Munchausen’, which cost around $46 million to make and earned only about $8 million at the box office. This meant it was incredibly unlikely that Wanner Brothers would take a risk with Gilliam, especially as they were lining up the ‘Harry Potter’ movies to be a huge money making franchise.

The cast of Harry Potter, all grown upThe cast of Harry Potter, all grown up

After the release of Columbus’s two ‘Harry Potter’ movies, Gilliam, who may still have been bitter, labeled them “shite”, saying, “the first two I thought were just shite. They missed the whole point of it; they missed the magic of it” in a 2006 interview. Some did agree, feeling that Columbus was too safe a choice to take on the ‘Harry Potter’ magic and made it too simplistic and aimed too much at the younger audience. Gilliam later told the BBC One Show, he “knew the studio would never hire me because they wanted a safe pair of hands, ones that would do what they wanted”.

Granted Columbus may have been a ‘safe choice’ for ‘Harry Potter’ and may have not delivered the massive ‘wow’ factor some were looking for in the first movies, its not to say he didn’t do a very good job. The first two movies, set up the franchise and allowed for future movies to grow and develop. Columbus laid out the ‘Harry Potter; story in the simplistic way and allowed viewers to get to know the characters they’d be following for the next eight years of their lives. Gilliam may have had a bigger imagination but he could have ended up making the films too ‘Gilliam’ and not enough ‘Harry Potter’.

Gilliam has since expressed his relief that he didn't get the ‘Harry Potter’ gig in the end. Speaking to The Guardian in 2009, the director said not getting the job was one of his lucky moments, adding That was one of my lucky moments," he told Total Film magazine. "I would have gone crazy. It's a fucking factory, working on Harry Potter. It is. The studios are staking everything on the success of those movies.” He would go on to explain that the major financial expectations of the movies would have stifled his creativity.

Chris Columbus, who directed the first two Harry Potter filmsChris Columbus, who directed the first two Harry Potter films

It’s hard to say if Chris Columbus really was the best choice to direct ‘Harry Potter’, who knows what someone like Tim Robbins or M. Night Shyamalan would have done. However it is probably better that Terry Gilliam didn't get  chance to start off the ‘Harry Potter’ franchise. With so much riding on these movies he didn't exactly have the best track record to be able to handle the financial implications. It’s also worth remembering that the ‘Harry Potter’ was always going to be an eight part series and different directors would have been involved and having such an individualistic director right at the beginning may not have been the best idea.


Tags: Terry Gilliam - Harry Potter


More Terry Gilliam

They're Very Naughty Boys: Ofcom Probes Monty Python Swearing

Communications watchdog Ofcom is investigating the Monty Python live show after bad language was broadcast before the watershed. Many of the complaints about the farewell...

Mick Jagger Hazes Monty Python In Video For (Mostly) Live Reunion

The last ever round of Monty Python reunion shows has been getting mixed reviews since its first night, July 1. While most fans likely filled...

The End Is Nigh: Monty Python Reunite For Final Round Of Gigs At The O2

In what may just be the biggest comeback in showbiz history, the remaining members of Monty Python have teamed up again for a number of...

Mick Jagger Takes The Mickey In Monty Python Reunion Tour Video

Mick Jagger has starred in a promotional video for the upcoming Monty Python live shows, the first of which will be held tonight at London's...


Benvenuto Cellini Trailer

Director Terry Gilliam enthuses about his upcoming production of Berlioz's opera 'Benvenuto Cellini' which is performed by English National Opera and will be broadcast live...

'The Last Night Of Monty Python' Stage Show To Be Shown In Cinemas

This latest announcement will see Monty Python fans simultaneously rejoice and mourn. The bizarre band of innovative comedians will regroup for the final time to...

Jupiter Ascending Trailer

Jupiter Jones has an unfortunate life, barely scraping by with her job cleaning toilets as a janitor. She wouldn't have thought that her life would...

'Zero Theorem' Difficult to Pin: Critics Divided Ahead of U.K Release

Amongst the post-Oscars films is The Zero Theorem, which stars the double Oscar-winning Christoph Waltz as Qohen Leth, a computer genius living as a recluse...



Aaron McCarthy's picture

Aaron McCarthy

"was always going to be an eight part series". Unless Warner Bros. and their band of merry men used Time Turners, or perhaps borrowed a DeLorean, the series was not always going to be in eight parts. Rowling always stated that she would write seven novels: on the outset the producers intended on seven films, they did not know the route Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows would take. Other than that, good points on the fact that an individualistic person like Gilliam would not have been an ideal director - unless he had signed on for all the films. I think Columbus did a good job in bringing the series to screen: he paved the way for others to develop and, arguably, without him the principal cast would have been somewhat different.

8 months 1 week ago
View Comments

Terry Gilliam Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Terry Gilliam

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All