Why Isn't The Beastie Boys vs Monster an Open and Shut Case?

0
0
Subscribe to Beastie Boys alerts

The Beastie Boys have a pretty strong case against Monster Beverage Corp; the manufacturer and seller of caffeinated energy drinks is being sued by hip hop outfit for the unauthorised use of their songs, including "Sabotage," "So What'cha Want" and "Make Some Noise."

Beastie BoysThe Beastie Boys transformed in to Lego by Adly Syairi Ramly

Monster has admitted to using the songs in the 2012 promotional video for the annual snowboarding competition the company organizes and sponsors in Canada called the "Ruckus in the Rockies." They admitted using the songs and said it was a mistake.

Monster's lawyer, Reid Kahn, told the jury the company "technically did violate the copyright", but only because an employee thought permission to use the music had been granted. "In this case, it turns out to have been a mistake," he said.

More: Beastie Boys Once Again Fight For Their Right... Copyright, That Is

So why isn’t this case open and closed, given Monster’s candid approach coupled with The Beastie Boy’s staunch approach to giving  up their tunes to market products? Well the key behind the whole thing is the amount The Beastie Boys are suggesting Monster pay them. 

"It stole the Beastie Boys' right to say no," Paul Garrity, a lawyer for The Beastie Boys, said. The band want a hot $2m from Monster, who are arguing that it’s simply too much. Reid Kahn, a lawyer for Monster, called that sum "illogical" and said the company should pay at most $125,000. We should take a second to think about the employee who thought the company had permission to use the music. 

Beastie Boys Star Ad-rock To Take The Stand In Copyright Infringement Case

Of course, The Beastie Boys are asking for more than they need financially, mainly because they really don’t need anything, financially. But by pushing so hard on Monster, the band are forcing the issue and telling other companies that they can’t simply use any song they want and hope the benefits outweigh the eventual court case. Not that that’s what Monster did or anything.


Contactmusic

Tags: Beastie Boys

0
0
Subscribe to Beastie Boys alerts
Advertisement

More Beastie Boys

Fight For Your Right: Beastie Boys Collect $1.7M In Monster Copyright Battle

The Beastie Boys have been awarded $1.7 (£1.1) million in a case battling the unauthorised use of their music in adverts by the fizzy drinks...

The Beastie Boys Now Embroiled In $2M Copyright Dispute

Anyone following pop culture news of late will have noticed that copyright disputes are kind of The Beastie Boys’ thing of late. Following the GoldieBlox...

Why Isn't The Beastie Boys vs Monster an Open and Shut Case?

The Beastie boys have a pretty strong case against Monster Beverage Corp; the manufacturer and seller of caffeinated energy drinks is being sued by hip...

Beastie Boys Once Again Fight For Their Right... Copyright, That Is.

The Beastie Boys are involved in another copyright lawsuit this week (the previous one against GoldieBlox ended in March with a settlement for an undisclosed...

Advertisement

GoldieBlox Removes Beastie Boys Song From Video To Avoid More Legal Disputes

GoldieBlox has withdrawn the Beastie Boys song from their viral video to avoid a legal battle with the band. The Californian toy company, used their...

The Beastie Boys Aren't Suing GoldieBlox After All, But Goldieblox Are Still Suing The Beasties

GoldieBlox may have shot themselves in the foot if they wanted to appear as the victims in the ongoing saga surrounding their online advertising campaign...

Toy Company Versus The Beastie Boys: The Copyright Saga Continues

The viral GoldieBlox ad, which flipped a Beastie Boys song on its head is pretty admirable, but that doesn’t save it from violating copyright. This...

Best Ad We've Ever Seen Turns Beastie Boys Sexist 'Girls' Around [Video]

In the face of a generation of mute princesses, vacuous models, and shallow celebrities, toy company GoldieBlox have designed a range of fun yet challenging...

Advertisement

Comments

Beastie Boys Newsletter

Subscribe to this news alert service to receive news and reviews on Beastie Boys

Unsubscribe | Unsubscribe All